Bernardo Magri
c32b51897e
All checks were successful
Check / eval (push) Successful in 3m44s
Light-theme accent buttons sat at 2.72:1 — under AA and under even the 3:1
large-text floor. Bernardo: fix it. The plan on file ("darken the label")
turned out to be IMPOSSIBLE, and measuring all 24 palettes is what showed
it: on a saturated mid-tone accent nothing clears 4.5 — cream base 2.72,
dark text 1.65. That is why adw-gtk3 ships white-on-accent at ~2.7. The
chip has to move.
The chip is now the accent pulled AWAY from the label: toward white when
the label is dark, toward black when it is cream. One factor (0.70), only
the anchor flips, so "solid accent button + base label" stays the design
and just shifts tone. Worst dark 4.86 (nord/bad), worst light 5.59
(summer-day). The old 0.90 chip failed SEVEN themes (miasma/bad 3.43,
rose-pine 2.70) — never only a light-theme bug, contrary to the item.
#129 rides along, and the two are one idea. #98 shipped an invisible button
with every check green because the background was not a palette role —
adw-gtk3 computed it from currentColor. So the guard is not a CSS lint
(which would flag the harmless generic-button rule and get muted) but
arithmetic: pin both ends and the pair becomes checkable.
check-theme-contrast.py now models GTK's own mix(a,b,f) = a + (b-a)*f —
READ from gtkcsscolorvalue.c:234, not assumed — and asserts base-on-chip
>= 4.5 for all 24 themes. Its negative test reproduces the item's reported
2.72/2.74 exactly from an independent model, which is the best evidence
available that the arithmetic matches the pixels.
Invariant to keep: pin the pair, or pin neither. Both chips are pinned now
(suggested + .default + destructive), where #98 pinned only destructive.
tools/dialog-shot.nix deliberately not built: the checker covers the
numbers, and a VM that only ever confirms arithmetic is maintenance for
nothing. Render if a new widget class appears.
Also sweeps #127 with the latch finding (ff5017e): symptom 2 solved, not
DPMS — which raises the odds the mitigation treats the wrong cause.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>